What the fuck J.K.
HOW DO YOU PERFECTION
oh my god
There are so many things wrong with this that I can’t even. First of all, Lupin WASN’T the first to die out of that group, Fred was. Fred got killed at Hogwarts way before Harry came back to find Lupin and Tonks lying dead some time later. Second of all, Lupin wasn’t the “first to rise,” he didn’t rise at all, they were all standing around, AND in fact he wasn’t the “first” of anything because he and Bill left the group TOGETHER, at the same time, to look for Moody’s body together. And I don’t even think they were “dining” at all. If I recall they were standing around drinking firewhiskey.
Point is, Hermione is right and Trelawney is and always will be a old fraud and an appalling teacher. :P